Following acrimonious debates within the bitcoin and ethereum communities over the past few years regarding governance decisions that ended in forks, there has been a wave of projects offering on-chain governance.
Prominent examples of protocols with on-chain governance include Tezos, EOS and Decred.
While these projects may have some value, I believe the push for on-chain governance is, in large part, the result of an intuition carried over from environments like nation-states and private companies, both of which are very different from crypto networks.
Implicitly, their belief is that we are seeing too much exit and not enough voice and we need to build better mechanisms for voice via formal on-chain governance.
Members of an organization, be it a nation, a business or a crypto network, have two possible responses when they're unhappy with its governance.
In crypto networks, users can try to change the way that the protocol operates through governance or they can choose to exit by either leaving the network or forking.
The tradeoff of prioritizing voice over exit is that democracies tend to be very inefficient compared to more technocratic forms of governance.
Open-source software governance tends to be technocratic with a relatively small group of stakeholders controlling the project.
Returning to blockchains, introducing on-chain governance to crypto networks is likely to make them more like nation-states with the inefficiencies that entails.
Off-chain governance may seem more unpredictable, but may prove more fertile ground for innovation for just that reason.
The Downside of Democracy
Published on Jun 22, 2018
by Coindesk | Published on Coinage
Coinage
Recent News
View All
Blockchain Bites: Bitcoin's Run, Uniswap's Hemorrhaging Value, Anchorage's Banking Bid
Bitcoin is nearing all-time highs in price and market cap last set three years ago.
Japan's megabanks to lead experiment with digital yen
We have, in order, Cheese Bank with a $3.3 million theft, Akropolis with its $2 million loss, Value DeFi with a whopping $6 million exploit and finally Origin Protocol's loss of $7 million.
Number of new Bitcoin addresses spikes amid growing FOMO
Japan's three largest banks, as part of a group of 30 private sector actors, are set to collaborate on an experiment with a digital yen.
Not just Wall Street: Quant trader explains why Bitcoin price is going up
Sam Trabucco, a quantitative trader at Alameda Research, believes four general factors are pushing up the price of Bitcoin.